Broken Underwriting: Why Hiring Underwriters Is So Hard, and How to Fix It
Underwriting talent is scarce. We look at why underwriting recruitment breaks down in Australia, and what employers can do to fix it.
73% of General Insurance professionals intend to stay in the industry, which for an industry facing talent shortages is reassuring.
However, HAYLO People’s 2026 Talent & Salary Insights Report found that over half of General Insurance talent are also actively or passively exploring new opportunities.
For employers, this presents a potential retention challenge, particularly when only 48% of General Insurance respondents said they were not looking at all. A further 24% were actively applying for roles, while 28% were casually monitoring job boards and the market.
In other words, a large proportion of employees do not need to be unhappy to leave, they just need to see something better.

The 2026 Talent & Insights Salary Report identifies talent shortages and knowledge loss as the number one challenge facing General Insurance, driven by difficulty attracting and retaining skilled people, an ageing workforce and weak training pathways.
Experienced professionals understand the value of their skills and may remain engaged in their current role while still being receptive to opportunities elsewhere. This makes passive talent an important consideration for employers looking to strengthen retention and protect their existing workforce.
According to HAYLO People’s 2026 Talent & Salary Insights Report salary remains the number one attraction driver for General Insurance professionals, but the priorities that follow highlight the growing importance of flexibility and career development.
Flexible start and finish times rank second, ahead of the ability to work from home in third place. Career development sits fourth, followed by compressed hours or a nine-day fortnight.

These findings reinforce the importance of offering more than a competitive remuneration. Businesses looking to attract and retain experienced professionals need to consider practical flexibility and clearly defined career progression alongside market-aligned salaries.
A promise of a “great culture” alone is unlikely to compete with employers that can demonstrate stronger flexibility, development opportunities and competitive remuneration.
The report also found that once pay and flexibility are aligned, recognition is the strongest retention driver for Claims and Underwriting professionals.
Employees want their contribution recognised and opportunities to have input into how work is being done. Strong leadership, trust, and psychological safety are also among the reasons why professionals will stay with a company.
This reinforces the importance of building an employee retention strategy around the factors employees genuinely value, rather than waiting until a resignation to review what could have been done differently.
HAYLO People’s 2026 Talent & Salary Insights Report gives a clear view of what industry professionals are looking for, what is driving movement and where expectations have shifted.
If you're looking to expand your team, or refine your retention strategy, get in touch here.
Download the full report to benchmark your employee offering against the market and understand what could make your people stay, or leave.
Demand for experienced underwriters, claims professionals and brokers remains strong across Sydney, Melbourne, Brisbane and the wider Australian market, so skilled General Insurance professionals are regularly approached about new opportunities even when they are performing well in their current role. HAYLO People's 2026 Talent & Salary Insights Report, which draws on national benchmarking data from more than 1,500 Insurance, Personal Injury and WHS professionals, gives employers a clear view of how openly the market is moving and why retention needs to be managed proactively.
Competitive, well-benchmarked salaries are the foundation, but experienced General Insurance professionals also weigh flexibility, a visible path for career development and genuine recognition of their contribution when deciding whether to stay. Employers who review these factors regularly against current market expectations are far better placed to keep their strongest people than those who only respond once a resignation lands.
High-performing employees often remain open to the right offer without showing obvious signs of disengagement, which is why regular, structured conversations about career goals, workload, remuneration and flexibility are so valuable. Benchmarking your offering against national and state-based salary data also highlights where your packages may be falling behind the market before it becomes a reason for your people to leave.
HAYLO People is an award-winning specialist recruitment agency, named Sourcr Agency of the Year 2025, with a General Insurance team drawn from the insurance industry itself and consultants partnering with insurers, underwriting agencies, TPAs and brokerages across NSW, Victoria, Queensland and nationally. Our recruitment process continues well beyond the placement, which is reflected in a 94% retention rate on hires, and our market insights help employers benchmark salaries, flexibility and career pathways to build a retention strategy that holds up in a competitive market.
Claims portfolios are in most states growing or have remained the same closing earlier this year. Psychological injuries are becoming more complex, and legislative demands are increasing. For Workers Compensation teams, ...
The 2026 HAYLO Salary & Talent Insights Report is in, and it paints a clear picture: the relationship between employers and employees is being renegotiated. Pay has gone up. Loyalty hasn't followed. Flexibility has becom...
The blog maps Australia's insurance broking career path, account executive to account manager to broker, with 2026 salary bands for Sydney, Melbourne, and Brisbane at each stage, plus the qualifications and behaviors tha...
If you work in NSW workers compensation you will already know the scheme has been under significant pressure. But the reforms passed through Parliament are different in character from what came before. They are not just ...
Demand for qualified injury management professionals is outpacing supply across Australia and the gap is widening. Whether you're hiring return to work coordinators, case managers, injury management advisors, or rehabili...