Whether it's a short term project or a sudden need to scale your team, we find the right people to keep your business running.
Contact UsIf you're a people leader, claims manager, or HR manager in workers compensation, personal injury, or insurance right now, you already feel it. Roles are harder to fill. The candidates you do find aren't quite right. Your best performers are fielding calls from competitors.
This is not a cycle. It is a structural shift in the Australian personal injury, workers compensation, and insurance talent market, and it is reshaping how smart employer’s hire.
At HAYLO People, we work exclusively in this space. We placed over 260 candidates in a recent 12-month period across workers compensation, injury management, WHS with a 94% placement retention rate. In early 2026, we surveyed more than 1,500 professionals across these sectors for our annual Talent and Salary Insights Survey. What we found reinforces what our consultants see on the ground every day.
Here is what is actually happening, and what it means for your hiring strategy.
The workers compensation and personal injury sectors carry an outsized share of mid-career and senior professionals who built their expertise under scheme structures that no longer exist in their original form. In NSW, Victoria, and Queensland, repeated legislative reforms have created a knowledge class, professionals who understand the architecture of the old and new scheme simultaneously, can navigate the grey, and still manage complex claims with clinical and legal nuance.
Many of those professionals are now in their mid-to-late 50s. They are not being replaced at the same rate they are leaving.
What this means for employers: the candidate pool for genuinely experienced workers compensation professionals is shrinking faster than it is being replenished. If your succession planning relies on being able to recruit those professionals when you need them, you are already behind.
What HAYLO People does about it: we maintain active relationships with passive talent across all Australian schemes, specifically including senior professionals who are not applying for roles, but who would consider the right opportunity. This is the only way to access that cohort. They are not on Seek.
NSW workers compensation has been under significant reform pressure, with changes to the nominal insurer model, increased scrutiny on whole person impairment assessments, and evolving definitions of entitlement generating demand for specialists who understand both the old framework and the direction of travel. Eligibility Specialists, in particular, have become a genuine scarcity hire, not because the role is new, but because the volume of complex threshold determinations has increased faster than the supply of people trained to handle them.
In Queensland, the three-insurer CTP market continues to create specialist hiring demand across WorkCover QLD, the private insurers, and the regulatory bodies that sit alongside them. In Victoria, the self-insured sector is actively building internal claims and injury management capability as employers look to move beyond agent management and take more direct control of their return-to-work outcomes.
Every time a scheme reforms, the short-term effect is to make experienced candidates scarcer and more expensive, because those who already have the knowledge become disproportionately valuable.
For hiring managers in these markets, the implication is clear. Lead time matters more than it used to. Roles that you might have expected to fill in four to six weeks are now taking eight to fourteen, and that is when the search is well-run. A poorly structured search in a niche scheme specialisation can take months.
Our consultants work scheme by scheme. Rebecca Harris specialises in Queensland workers compensation and Injury Management. Ashlea Smith covers NSW. Adam Coyne leads our Victorian practice. That scheme-level depth is not a marketing claim. It is what makes the difference between finding the right candidate in six weeks and spending four months running the wrong search.
Our 2026 Talent and Salary Insights Survey which is due to be released in July, drew responses from more than 1,500 professionals across personal injury, general insurance, and WHS, confirmed something we see consistently in our day-to-day work: the majority of experienced candidates in these sectors are passive. They are employed. They are not applying for roles. But a significant portion of them are open to a conversation if the right opportunity comes to them directly.
This is not a temporary state caused by a tight market. It is the permanent condition of most mid-to-senior talent in specialist industries. The people who are actively applying on job boards at any given moment are not, as a general rule, the people who are hardest to replace.
For employers who have built their recruitment strategy around job board advertising, this is a fundamental problem. You are fishing in the part of the lake where the fish are least valuable, and missing most of the market.
What changes this is a recruitment partner with genuine, current relationships across the candidate pool, not a database of historical CVs, but active relationships with professionals who trust them enough to have a candid conversation about their career.
HAYLO People's placement retention rate of 94% reflects this. We are not moving people for the sake of moving them. We are identifying candidates whose current role has a specific gap that the new role closes. That precision is what produces retention outcomes.
One of the sharpest tensions emerging from our survey data is what we call the flexibility-pay paradox. Candidates across personal injury, WHS, and general insurance consistently rank workplace flexibility as a top priority. But when offers are made and accepted, base salary remains the primary driver of movement.
The practical consequence: candidates who said flexibility was their priority will still accept a role with a below-market salary if the work-from-home arrangement is right, but they will stay in a fully flexible role with a below-market salary for far longer than employers expect. And they will leave the moment a competitor offers both.
Employers who think they are managing salary expectations through flexible work arrangements are often actually deferring attrition, not preventing it.
Our survey found a consistent gap between the pay rises candidates expected and the pay rises they received. In sectors where salary transparency has increased and candidates increasingly benchmark against market data before every performance review cycle, that gap is a attrition risk.
For organisations hiring into personal injury, claims, and WHS roles right now, the commercial advice is direct. If your salary bands have not been reviewed against current market rates in the past 12 months, they are likely to be costing you candidate quality and offer acceptance rates. We provide current market benchmarking as a standard part of our engagement, because employers who go to market with outdated salary expectations waste time, damage candidate relationships, and frequently make a worse hire than they would have at the right rate.
AI is changing claims management, return-to-work coordination, underwriting, and case management. Sentiment has shifted from scepticism to anxiety across the workforce, and our 2026 survey findings reflected a labour market increasingly aware that AI is not just automating administrative tasks but beginning to touch the analytical work that defines professional roles.
But the most important thing our survey revealed is not that people are worried about AI. It is that the professionals who are learning to work with AI tools are pulling ahead of those who are not, in productivity, in demonstrable value to employers, and in compensation outcomes.
The capability gap is real and it is widening. Employers in workers compensation and insurance who are building hiring criteria around AI-adjacent capability, not asking candidates whether they use AI, but whether they can demonstrate what it changes about their output, are identifying a quality differential that older hiring criteria miss entirely.
There is a second-order effect that matters for hiring strategy. As AI takes on more volume-based claims processing, the roles that remain distinctly human, complex injury management, stakeholder negotiation, clinical reasoning, rehabilitation coordination, employer relationship management, become more critical and harder to staff. The structural shift is toward human skills. The demand for professionals who do the work that machines cannot do is increasing, not decreasing.
This does not make AI irrelevant to your hiring decisions. It makes the criteria for a good hire more nuanced than they used to be.
We have seen a marked increase in counter-offer acceptance rates over the past 18 months, specifically in workers compensation and injury management. This is partly a labour market effect and partly a structural feature of the current moment.
When employers have invested significant time and cost in developing a claims professional who understands their scheme, their systems, and their key stakeholder relationships, they will fight harder to keep them than they did three years ago, because they know how hard it is to replace them. Counter-offers are more aggressive. Retention bonuses are more common. Promises about future flexibility and career progression are being made faster and more specifically.
For candidates, this creates genuine decision complexity. The role they were excited to leave for is real, and so is the improved package their existing employer is now offering.
What this means for employers hiring in this space: slow processes lose good candidates, not just to other offers but to counter-offers that arrive precisely because the candidate resigned. A four-week interview process is a four-week window for your target candidate's current employer to respond. Compress the process. Move decisively. Have the offer ready when the second interview confirms the candidate is right. We coach clients and candidates through this dynamic explicitly, because a counter-offer lost placement helps no one.
The workers compensation, personal injury, injury management, and insurance talent market in 2026 is not simply tight. It is structurally constrained by a pipeline that has not kept pace with demand, reformed by scheme changes that create constant new specialisation requirements, and complicated by candidate behaviours and expectations that do not map neatly onto the hiring practices most organisations built during a different labour market era.
The employers performing well in this environment share a common set of practices. They build talent relationships before they have open roles. They move quickly when the right candidate is available. They benchmark salary annually rather than when a resignation forces their hand. They work with recruitment partners who have genuine, current, scheme-specific relationships in the candidate market rather than generic databases.
HAYLO People was built specifically for this market. We do not recruit across every industry. We recruit exclusively in personal injury, workers compensation, injury management, return to work, WHS, general insurance, insurance broking, and underwriting. Every consultant on our team has a defined specialisation and an active candidate network in that specialisation. That depth is what makes the difference when the role you need to fill has a short candidate list and a long list of requirements.
Talk to HAYLO People
If you have a role to fill in any of these disciplines, or if you are planning to hire in the next three to six months and want to understand what the current market looks like before you go to it, we want to talk to you. A practical conversation about the market, what you are looking for, and whether we can help you find it.
Visit our consultants team page or reach out directly to the consultant who specialises in your state and sector.
New South Wales: Ashlea Smith
Queensland: Rebecca Harris
Victoria: Adam Coyne
Liability & Life Insurance (National): Dominic Sheppard
Work Health Safety Daniel Scally
We are HAYLO People. Specialist recruitment for specialist sectors.
HAYLO People is an Australian specialist recruitment agency placing permanent, temporary, and contract professionals across personal injury, workers compensation, injury management, return to work, WHS, general insurance, insurance broking, underwriting, and rehabilitation. Sourcr Agency of the Year 2025. 94% placement retention rate. Data sourced from the HAYLO People 2026 Talent and Salary Insights Survey (1,500+ respondents).
If you work in NSW workers compensation you will already know the scheme has been under significant pressure. But the reforms passed through Parliament are different in character from what came before. They are not just ...
Demand for qualified injury management professionals is outpacing supply across Australia and the gap is widening. Whether you're hiring return to work coordinators, case managers, injury management advisors, or rehabili...
Hiring in general insurance has fundamentally changed. Roles aren't lost to competitors, they're lost to speed and indecision. Danielle Marshall, Co-Founder at HAYLO People, explains why most insurers are still hiring li...
