Whether it's a short term project or a sudden need to scale your team, we find the right people to keep your business running.
Contact Us
That reset has a direct and immediate consequence for the labour market. It is creating urgent, sustained demand for a type of professional that most NSW organisations have never had to recruit for in meaningful numbers before.
Eligibility Specialists.
At HAYLO People, we recruit exclusively across workers compensation, personal injury, and the broader insurance sector. We have been tracking this shift closely, placing Eligibility professionals across NSW and Victoria, and advising both employers and candidates on what the role requires and what the market looks like. This blog sets out what is driving demand, what strong candidates look like, and what organisations need to understand if they want to attract and retain this cohort.
The NSW Government passed two landmark pieces of legislation in 2025: the Workers Compensation Legislation Amendment Act 2025 and the Workers Compensation Legislation Amendment (Reform and Modernisation) Act 2025. Together, they touch almost every corner of the scheme. But for the purpose of understanding why Eligibility roles are emerging as a priority hire, the most significant changes fall into three areas.
1. The threshold for psychological injury claims has been raised significantly
Psychological injury claims have been the single biggest driver of scheme instability in NSW. High claim volumes, long durations, contested liability, and inconsistent impairment assessment outcomes have put enormous strain on the scheme's financial sustainability for years.
The 2025 reforms address this directly. From 1 July 2026, the Whole Person Impairment (WPI) threshold required to access weekly payments beyond 130 weeks rises to 25%. It increases again to 28% from 1 July 2029. The threshold for Work Injury Damages (common law claims) for primary psychological injuries moves to 25% WPI from the same date.
The Psychiatric Impairment Rating Scale (PIRS), long criticised for producing inconsistent outcomes, is also being replaced. The NSW Chief Psychiatrist is developing a new assessment tool designed to deliver more defensible and standardised impairment ratings across the scheme.
The practical consequence is significant. The eligibility determination at the front end of a psychological injury claim now carries far more weight. If a claim does not meet the threshold, it does not proceed in the same way. Getting that determination right, early, and consistently is no longer optional.
2. Liability tests for psychological injury are now more prescriptive
The reforms introduce a relevant event test for psychological injury claims. To be compensable, a worker must now demonstrate that their injury arose from a specific qualifying event, such as bullying, excessive work demands, or a traumatic incident, and that employment was the main contributing factor.
The reasonable management action defence has also been clarified. Where an injury is significantly caused by reasonable management action taken in a reasonable manner, including performance management, restructuring, or disciplinary processes, compensation is not payable.
A middle ground exists for conduct-based claims still under investigation: workers may receive interim payments of 75% of pre-injury earnings for up to 42 days while liability is determined. That 42-day window is tight. It puts real operational pressure on insurers and agents to assess, investigate, and decide quickly and accurately.
3. Premium and employer obligations are also shifting
For policies issued or renewed after 4pm on 30 June 2026, employers will be required to pay a fixed excess, likely up to two weeks of income support, at the start of a new claim. The icare Nominal Insurer's premium target collection rate is also frozen for two years, running from 30 June 2026 to 30 June 2028. Separately, a new intensive return-to-work program will provide an additional 52 weeks of medical benefits and income replacement for workers with psychological injuries, designed to support sustained recovery and reduce long-term scheme liability.
These changes add further pressure on insurers and scheme agents to ensure every claim entering the system is legitimate, properly categorised, and managed correctly from the outset. The cost of a poorly assessed claim is no longer just operational. It has direct financial consequences for employers, scheme agents, and the broader scheme.
Here is the honest answer: reforms like these only work if someone is doing the hard, technical work of assessing claims properly at the point of lodgement. Raising WPI thresholds on paper achieves nothing if the determination process is under-resourced, inconsistent, or left to case managers whose primary skill set is claim progression rather than liability analysis.
NSW workers compensation Eligibility Specialists exist to sit at the front of the claims lifecycle and make those calls. They assess whether a claim meets the legislative criteria for acceptance. They apply the relevant event test. They consider the reasonable management action defence. They determine whether interim entitlements apply and for how long. They do this under real time pressure, with incomplete information, and with full awareness that their determination has significant financial and legal consequences downstream.
That is a specialised and demanding skill set. Until recently, very few NSW insurers or scheme agents, including those within the Nominal Insurer scheme, had built a dedicated team around it. That is now changing fast.
The reforms have created a forcing function.
Organisations that were managing eligibility informally, typically absorbed into standard case management, now need dedicated people who can do this work properly, consistently, and at volume. The growth in demand is happening across the NSW scheme, but it is the Nominal Insurer scheme and its appointed agents where the volume and urgency are most acute. HAYLO People is already working with organisations at the forefront of building these functions.
Not every workers compensation professional is suited to Eligibility. The role rewards a very particular type of thinker: someone comfortable sitting with ambiguity, applying complex legislative frameworks to real-world facts, and making independent determinations that will face scrutiny.
Based on HAYLO People's direct experience placing Eligibility Specialists across NSW and Victoria, the candidates who perform well in this space consistently bring:
Deep technical knowledge of the NSW Workers Compensation Acts and applicable regulations
Experience managing complex, disputed, or long-tail claims, not just high-volume standard caseloads
Hands-on experience within the Nominal Insurer (icare) scheme, Treasury Managed Fund (TMF), and/or self-insured environments
Strong written reasoning and analytical skills, because determinations must be defensible under review
The ability to make independent, time-pressured decisions without constant escalation
Psychological injury experience, particularly familiarity with impairment assessment, work capacity evaluation, and the relevant legislative tests
Psychological injury expertise is increasingly the differentiating factor in this market. Given the reform focus, someone who has managed complex psych claims at depth, and who understands how impairment ratings, work capacity, and legislative thresholds interact, is commanding a meaningful salary premium right now.
HAYLO People is a specialist recruitment agency operating exclusively across personal injury, workers compensation, injury management, return to work, and the broader insurance sector. This is not a generalist firm that dabbles in insurance. It is all we do, and that focus has real consequences for the quality of our candidate relationships and our market intelligence.
We hold the largest personal injury talent database in Australia. That database is built on years of direct engagement with professionals who are genuinely active and skilled in this space, not candidates scraped from job boards. We know who is looking, who is open to a conversation, and who the high performers are in each state and each specialisation.
Specifically for Eligibility recruitment in NSW, HAYLO People brings:
A proven track record of placing Eligibility Specialists across both the Nominal Insurer (icare) scheme and Treasury Managed Fund (TMF) environments in NSW and Victoria
Deep understanding of what separates strong Eligibility candidates from those who struggle with the demands of the role
Active, exclusive relationships with candidates holding NI scheme experience, TMF experience, and existing Eligibility determination experience
Real-time salary benchmarking and market intelligence on candidate availability, salary expectations, and competitor hiring activity
Direct experience advising organisations building Eligibility functions from the ground up, including role design, levelling, and team structure
When you brief HAYLO People on an Eligibility role, you are not getting a keyword search against a generic database. You are getting access to a curated network of professionals that most organisations simply cannot reach through standard recruitment channels.
Eligibility roles in NSW are now commanding a clear premium over standard case management positions. That premium reflects the specialised skill set, the weight of the decision-making responsibility, and the tightness of the available candidate pool. The figures below are based on HAYLO People's active market intelligence as at May 2026.
All figures are base salary in AUD, excluding superannuation. Actual remuneration will vary by organisation type, scheme environment, claim complexity, and individual candidate profile. Contact HAYLO People for a more detailed salary benchmarking conversation specific to your situation.
If you are currently working in NSW workers compensation, particularly within the Nominal Insurer scheme, across complex or technical claims portfolios, or within a TMF environment, and you are considering what a genuine step up might look like, Eligibility is worth a serious conversation.
The transition is not for everyone. But for the right case manager, it can be a career-defining move. The work is more analytically demanding than a standard caseload. The pay reflects that. The exposure to legislative interpretation, liability analysis, and high-stakes decision-making builds a profile that opens significant doors over time.
Right now, there is real and active demand from well-credentialled employers who are building these teams across the Nominal Insurer scheme. The timing is good for the right person.
HAYLO People has guided a number of case managers through this transition. We can give you a frank, honest picture of what the role involves day-to-day, what employers are actually looking for at each level, and what a realistic salary expectation looks like for someone with your specific background. No obligation. Just a useful conversation.
HAYLO People regularly fields questions from both employers and candidates about Eligibility roles in NSW. Here are the most common.
What does a workers compensation Eligibility Specialist do in NSW?
An Eligibility Specialist assesses incoming workers compensation claims against the legislative criteria set out in the Workers Compensation Act 1987 and the Workplace Injury Management and Workers Compensation Act 1998. They determine whether a claim should be accepted, declined, or deferred, and apply tests such as the relevant event criteria and the reasonable management action defence for psychological injury claims. Their decisions shape scheme liability and directly influence financial outcomes for insurers, scheme agents, and employers.
Why are NSW insurers and scheme agents hiring Eligibility Specialists now?
The 2025 NSW workers compensation reforms, including the Workers Compensation Legislation Amendment Act 2025 and the Workers Compensation Legislation Amendment (Reform and Modernisation) Act 2025, have raised the stakes for front-end claim assessment significantly. Higher WPI thresholds, tighter liability tests for psychological injury, and tighter timeframes for interim entitlement decisions have created a need for dedicated professionals who can make these determinations accurately and consistently at volume.
What experience do I need to become a workers compensation Eligibility Specialist in NSW?
Most Eligibility Specialist roles require a solid background in technical workers compensation case management, ideally within the Nominal Insurer (icare) scheme or a TMF environment. Strong legislative knowledge, experience with complex or disputed claims, and the ability to make independent written determinations are typically essential. Psychological injury experience is increasingly valued given the current reform focus.
Which recruitment agency specialises in workers compensation Eligibility roles in NSW?
HAYLO People is a specialist recruitment agency focused exclusively on personal injury, workers compensation, and insurance. We have a proven track record placing Eligibility Specialists across the NSW Nominal Insurer scheme and TMF environments, and hold the largest personal injury talent database in Australia. We work with both employers building Eligibility functions and candidates looking to move into this space.
What salary can a workers compensation Eligibility Specialist expect in NSW in 2026?
Based on current market activity, Eligibility Specialists in NSW are earning between $95,000 and $115,000 base salary at the experienced level. Senior Eligibility Specialists typically earn $115,000 to $130,000, and Eligibility Team Leaders or Managers $130,000 to $150,000 or above. These figures reflect a clear market premium over standard case management roles, driven by the specialised skill set and tightness of the candidate pool.
Talk to HAYLO People About Eligibility Recruitment in NSW
Whether you are an insurer or scheme agent building an Eligibility function, looking to strengthen an existing team, or a workers compensation professional exploring what a move into Eligibility might look like, HAYLO People is the right starting point.
We know this market, we know these candidates, and we know what good looks like. Happy to connect over a call or a coffee.
Reach out to Dominic Sheppard: dominic.sheppard@haylopeople.com.au
Demand for qualified injury management professionals is outpacing supply across Australia and the gap is widening. Whether you're hiring return to work coordinators, case managers, injury management advisors, or rehabili...
Hiring in general insurance has fundamentally changed. Roles aren't lost to competitors, they're lost to speed and indecision. Danielle Marshall, Co-Founder at HAYLO People, explains why most insurers are still hiring li...
The HAYLO People Talent & Salary Insights Survey is a free resource for the industry to help shape decisions around salaries, benefits, and employee value propositions, continuing to improve the General Insurance, Person...
